In a class of 23 students, 7 study Math, 8 study English, and 5 study Science. It is implied that every student studies at least one of these subjects. The goal is to find the number of students studying all three subjects using Venn diagram directions.

Discrete MathematicsSet TheoryPrinciple of Inclusion-ExclusionVenn DiagramsCombinatorics
2025/6/22

1. Problem Description

In a class of 23 students, 7 study Math, 8 study English, and 5 study Science. It is implied that every student studies at least one of these subjects. The goal is to find the number of students studying all three subjects using Venn diagram directions.

2. Solution Steps

Let MM, EE, and SS represent the sets of students studying Math, English, and Science, respectively. Let xx be the number of students who study all three subjects. We are given:
M=7|M| = 7
E=8|E| = 8
S=5|S| = 5
MES=23|M \cup E \cup S| = 23
We use the Principle of Inclusion-Exclusion to find the number of students studying at least one of the subjects:
MES=M+E+SMEMSES+MES|M \cup E \cup S| = |M| + |E| + |S| - |M \cap E| - |M \cap S| - |E \cap S| + |M \cap E \cap S|
Let n(ME)n(M \cap E) represent the number of students studying both Math and English, n(MS)n(M \cap S) represent the number of students studying both Math and Science, and n(ES)n(E \cap S) represent the number of students studying both English and Science. Let xx represent the number of students studying all three subjects.
23=7+8+5MEMSES+x23 = 7 + 8 + 5 - |M \cap E| - |M \cap S| - |E \cap S| + x
23=20MEMSES+x23 = 20 - |M \cap E| - |M \cap S| - |E \cap S| + x
ME+MS+ESx=2023|M \cap E| + |M \cap S| + |E \cap S| - x = 20 - 23
ME+MS+ESx=3|M \cap E| + |M \cap S| + |E \cap S| - x = -3
ME+MS+ES=x3|M \cap E| + |M \cap S| + |E \cap S| = x - 3
We know that MEx|M \cap E| \ge x, MSx|M \cap S| \ge x, and ESx|E \cap S| \ge x. Also, MEmin(M,E)=min(7,8)=7|M \cap E| \le \min(|M|, |E|) = \min(7, 8) = 7. Similarly, MSmin(M,S)=min(7,5)=5|M \cap S| \le \min(|M|, |S|) = \min(7, 5) = 5, and ESmin(E,S)=min(8,5)=5|E \cap S| \le \min(|E|, |S|) = \min(8, 5) = 5.
Also, the number of students studying only math is 7(MEx)(MSx)x=7MEMS+x7 - (|M \cap E| - x) - (|M \cap S| - x) - x = 7 - |M \cap E| - |M \cap S| + x.
The number of students studying only English is 8(MEx)(ESx)x=8MEES+x8 - (|M \cap E| - x) - (|E \cap S| - x) - x = 8 - |M \cap E| - |E \cap S| + x.
The number of students studying only Science is 5(MSx)(ESx)x=5MSES+x5 - (|M \cap S| - x) - (|E \cap S| - x) - x = 5 - |M \cap S| - |E \cap S| + x.
We know that ME+MS+ES=x3|M \cap E| + |M \cap S| + |E \cap S| = x - 3.
Since MEx|M \cap E| \ge x, MSx|M \cap S| \ge x, and ESx|E \cap S| \ge x, then x33xx - 3 \ge 3x, implying 2x32x \le -3 or x1.5x \le -1.5, which is impossible, because xx has to be a non-negative integer.
We can rewrite the Inclusion-Exclusion formula as
ME+MS+ES=2023+x=x3|M \cap E| + |M \cap S| + |E \cap S| = 20 - 23 + x = x - 3.
Each of ME,MS,ES|M \cap E|, |M \cap S|, |E \cap S| must be at least xx. Also, the number of students in each category must be non-negative. Let's consider the minimum possible values for ME|M \cap E|, MS|M \cap S|, and ES|E \cap S|. We know that
MEx|M \cap E| \geq x
MSx|M \cap S| \geq x
ESx|E \cap S| \geq x
Adding these we get ME+MS+ES3x|M \cap E| + |M \cap S| + |E \cap S| \geq 3x so x33xx-3 \geq 3x, which means 32x-3 \geq 2x or x1.5x \leq -1.5. This is clearly not possible. Thus, there is an error in the problem statement, or a misinterpretation.
Let A be number of students that take only math.
Let B be number of students that take only english.
Let C be number of students that take only science.
Let D be the number of students that take both math and english.
Let E be the number of students that take both math and science.
Let F be the number of students that take both english and science.
Let G be the number of students that take all three subjects.
Then we have:
A + B + C + D + E + F + G = 23
A + D + E + G = 7
B + D + F + G = 8
C + E + F + G = 5
Sum the last three equations
A + B + C + 2D + 2E + 2F + 3G = 20
Subtracting the first equation from this result we get
D + E + F + 2G = -3
This is impossible since all variables must be nonnegative. Thus the problem is flawed.

3. Final Answer

The problem is flawed; there is no solution.

Related problems in "Discrete Mathematics"

The problem has two parts. Part (a) presents criteria for selecting school prefects based on student...

AlgorithmsPseudo-codeFlowchartsLogicConditional Statements
2025/6/29

The image contains multiple questions related to ICT. I will answer questions (iii), (iv), (v) and (...

Number Base ConversionBoolean AlgebraLogic Circuits
2025/6/29

We have four questions to answer based on the provided image: * Question 37: Find the index of the...

ArraysAlgorithmsExponentsPascal ProgrammingBitwise OperationsCombinatorics
2025/6/29

We are given a flowchart and two questions related to it. Question 35 asks for the output of the flo...

AlgorithmsFlowchartsIterationLoopsSequences
2025/6/29

We need to answer multiple-choice questions related to computer architecture, networking, number sys...

Number SystemsBinaryHexadecimalBCDLogic GatesASCIIBoolean Algebra
2025/6/29

The image presents a number sequence: 1, 5, 14, 30, 55, ... and asks to find the next number in the ...

Number SequencesPattern RecognitionSeries
2025/6/26

The image contains handwritten text: "7w Sm" and "4 member commit". It seems the problem wants us to...

CombinatoricsCombinationsFactorials
2025/6/18

We are asked to find the number of 3-digit integers greater than 430 that can be formed using the di...

CountingCombinatoricsPermutations3-digit integersDigit restrictions
2025/6/18

A company manager wants to form a committee. There are 12 staff members. He wants to choose the memb...

CombinatoricsSubsetsCommittee FormationCounting
2025/6/17

A manager of a company wants to form a committee with 5 members. There are 12 candidates. Two candid...

CombinatoricsCombinationsCommittee Formation
2025/6/17